Understanding the Risks: What HOA Boards Should Know About Insurance Vulnerabilities

For homeowners associations (HOAs), insurance provides a critical layer of protection against unforeseen losses. But as insurance providers grow increasingly selective about which communities they insure, HOAs must recognize that their own financial practices and risk profile play a major role in determining coverage availability and premium costs.

Insurers are paying close attention to certain red flags that increase liability—and in today’s tightening market, those risk factors can be the difference between affordable protection and unaffordable premiums. Here are four key concerns that HOA insurance providers are watching closely, as well as mitigation techniques for each:

  1. Financial Mismanagement and Fraud

One of the biggest red flags for insurers is poor financial oversight. Embezzlement, vendor kickbacks, and unauthorized spending by board members or HOA employees can result in significant financial losses and trigger costly claims. Beyond the immediate damage, these actions often deplete reserve funds, create financial instability, and make the HOA a high-risk client from an insurer’s perspective. Here are a few key steps for reducing the risk of financial mismanagement and fraud:

  • Require dual signatures on high-dollar checks
  • Conduct regular financial audits
  • Work with an independent HOA accounting firm like Clear View to provide oversight, transparency, and monthly financial reviews
  1. Escalating Insurance Premiums

The insurance market for HOAs is currently facing significant pressure. Factors such as inflation, aging infrastructure, and increasing natural disasters are driving premiums higher year after year. In fact, according to the Wall Street Journal, associations in wildfire- and hurricane-prone areas have seen rate increases exceeding 50%—and in some cases, insurers are refusing to renew policies at all. For some associations, this has resulted in budget deficits or the need for special assessments just to keep coverage in place.

Faced with the possibility of escalating premiums, communities can take steps such as:

  • Planning ahead with conservative budgeting and long-term forecasting
  • Conducting regular insurance reviews to avoid gaps and prevent premium spikes
  • Partnering with experts who can help manage insurance renewals and ensure that your financials support favorable underwriting
  1. Regulatory Compliance Challenges

In some states, new legislation is placing additional requirements on HOAs to conduct reserve studies and fund major repairs appropriately. Falling behind on compliance can lead to penalties—and it signals to insurers that the HOA is not prioritizing long-term planning or financial stability. Therefore, it’s crucial to stay informed about legal updates in your state, and partner with professionals such as Clear View HOA Financial who can assist with reserve study planning and compliance monitoring. Additionally, facilitate board education and participation in ongoing governance training.

  1. Insurance Market Contraction

Due to the increased risks of insuring HOAs, some carriers are exiting the market entirely—especially in high-risk regions or communities with poor financial oversight. Unfortunately, fewer insurers mean less competition and higher premiums for everyone else. Since communities that lack transparency or documentation are likely at higher risk of being dropped, it’s crucial to take steps such as the following:

  • Document everything, including budget decisions, maintenance schedules, vendor contracts, and financial reports
  • Engage professional management or financial advisors to ensure that your HOA presents a strong, stable profile
  • Consider Crime and Fidelity Insurance coverage to protect against internal fraud and demonstrate proactive risk management

How Clear View HOA Financial Can Help Reduce Your Risk Profile

At Clear View, we work closely with HOA boards to ensure that your financials are accurate, audit-ready, and compliant with best practices. By improving transparency and maintaining strong financial controls, your HOA will become a more attractive and less risky client to insurance providers.

Our services include:

  • Full-service HOA accounting and budget forecasting
  • Reserve study tracking and reserve fund management
  • Annual audit and tax filing coordination
  • Monthly financial reviews with peer verification
  • Insurance renewal support with detailed financial documentation

In today’s challenging insurance landscape, the best way to keep premiums manageable and coverage secure is by running a financially disciplined, well-documented association. Let Clear View help you build a financial foundation that insurers trust—contact us today and schedule a consultation to review your HOA’s financial health!

related news & insights.

  • Protecting Your Community: What HOA Boards Need to Know About Embezzlement

    Protecting Your Community: What HOA Boards Need to Know About Embezzlement When residents contribute monthly dues, they trust their HOA to manage those funds responsibly. [...]